However, after further investigation...
I originally listened to the songs through my monitor and my first impressions were somewhat different to what they are now.
Having now played them repeatedly through headphones, the happy story has ended brutally. Firstly, I recognized the original production on both Ronald Biggs tracks. Then it became clear that the same was true for all the Swindle tracks.
I have since worked out the following:
No Feelings: From 2002 3CD Box Set. Manchester Square, December 1976. Fake.
Submission: From the 2012 Box set. The solo guitar frequency has been boosted. A good idea, but not good enough. Fake.
Diagram shows comparison between "Submission outtake" (top) and "Submission - track 14 Deluxe Boxset" (bottom). It's the same track minus the last two seconds on the fake one. Both tracks match note by note. The diagram shows where the frequency is enhanced.
My Way: From the common Swindle CD. Lead vocal and guitar frequencies decreased while strings frequency is enhanced. Fake.
Anarchy In The UK. From 2002 3CD Box Set. Left channel is doctored. Fake.
Similar doctoring has been applied to all the mixes in this collection.
To conclude: All the Swindle material originates from the official Swindle CD. Fakes.
All Bollocks material originates from the 2012 Deluxe Box Set, with the exception of No Feelings (see above). Anarchy may have been taken from 2002 Box Set - either way, the outcome is the same. Fakes.
Black Leather & Here We Go Again come from the Sex Pack vinyl single. Why bother?
Finally, what is a master tape? A master tape is the two track recording you've got from the sound you choose from the 24 tracks mixing desk.
I don't believe the story telling that accompanies these recordings about Universal Music checking the 2 tracks content. You don't mix again material that is already mixed, you just listen to what you've got. The storyteller ignored what actually is a master, and must think the sound comes from the 24 tracks.
Verdict. I feel disappointed and hope the person(s) involved only did it for a joke. If not, they need to take sleeping pills for a while.
You could argue, on the evidence so far, the one thing the faker(s) did get right is these recordings are both bollocks and a swindle!
Someone out there may have a different view and still be convinced they are genuine, but that's not how it looks to me - they are fakes.
Don't fall for it.
You need 60 seconds to produce a new unreleased mix. First you open a song..... |